dfsroto · projections · optimizer · data policy

Kalshi NFL player props — model probability vs market price

2545 priced sides across 1437 open Kalshi player-stat markets, 40 player-stats anchored to Pinnacle's line. Updated 2026-09-16 16:54Z.

Each row is one side of one Kalshi contract: the price you would pay, the probability the model assigns to that side, and the return that implies after Kalshi's 7% taker fee. Where Pinnacle has posted a line, the model's distribution is re-centred so its probability at Pinnacle's line matches Pinnacle's de-vigged price (70% weight), then the whole ladder is priced from that. Rows without a Pinnacle line are the model alone. This is data — a probability next to a price — not advice; thin ladders can move on a single order.

Price = cost per $1 contractp = model probability this side paysROI = (p − price − fee) / priceμ model mean → anchored mean
PlayerStatStrikeSidePricepROIPinnacle lineμ modelμ usedbid / ask
Josh Allen BUFrushing yards60+YES0.1319%36%30.5 (50% over)36.3137.570.12 / 0.13
James Cook III BUFrushing yards130+YES0.1217%34%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.09 / 0.12
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards140+YES0.1318%27%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.08 / 0.13
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards50+NO0.3647%25%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.64 / 0.65
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards130+YES0.1722%25%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.16 / 0.17
DJ Moore BUFreceptions4+NO0.3748%23%4.5 (49% over)2.133.950.63 / 0.68
James Cook III BUFrushing yards120+YES0.1722%23%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.12 / 0.17
James Cook III BUFrushing yards110+YES0.2128%23%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.19 / 0.21
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards60+YES0.1418%22%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.11 / 0.14
DJ Moore BUFreceptions3+NO0.2330%20%4.5 (49% over)2.133.950.77 / 0.85
Keon Coleman BUFreceptions3+YES0.1721%16%1.5 (36% over)1.881.490.11 / 0.17
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceptions4+NO0.4453%15%3.5 (58% over)2.33.660.56 / 0.57
DJ Moore BUFreceptions5+NO0.5464%15%4.5 (49% over)2.133.950.46 / 0.47
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards60+NO0.4958%15%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.51 / 0.52
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards50+NO0.4857%14%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.52 / 0.53
Jameson Williams DETreceptions4+NO0.3946%14%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.61 / 0.62
James Cook III BUFrushing yards100+YES0.2935%13%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.28 / 0.29
Jameson Williams DETreceptions7+YES0.1214%12%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.11 / 0.12
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards50+NO0.3945%11%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.61 / 0.62
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards70+NO0.5968%11%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.41 / 0.43
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceptions3+NO0.2934%11%3.5 (58% over)2.33.660.71 / 0.76
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceptions8+NO0.5360%9%7.5 (49% over)5.327.010.47 / 0.48
Jared Goff DETpassing yards300+YES0.3136%9%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.3 / 0.31
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards40+NO0.3944%8%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.61 / 0.64
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards120+YES0.2428%8%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.22 / 0.24
Isaac TeSlaa DETreceptions2+NO0.5763%7%1.5 (43% over)0.91.360.43 / 0.44
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards60+NO0.5156%7%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.49 / 0.51
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards50+YES0.2226%7%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.19 / 0.22
Jameson Williams DETreceptions3+NO0.2529%7%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.75 / 0.78
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards80+NO0.6975%6%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.31 / 0.32
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards90+NO0.7581%6%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.25 / 0.27
Sam LaPorta DETreceptions4+NO0.3943%6%4.5 (46% over)3.374.210.61 / 0.66
Keon Coleman BUFreceiving yards15+YES0.4853%5%13.5 (50% over)28.27230.46 / 0.48
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards150+YES0.1214%5%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.11 / 0.12
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards100+NO0.8086%5%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.2 / 0.21
James Cook III BUFrushing yards90+YES0.3943%5%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.37 / 0.39
Jared Goff DETpassing yards275+YES0.4549%4%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.44 / 0.45
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards60+YES0.7378%4%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.7 / 0.73
Jared Goff DETpassing yards325+YES0.2124%4%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.18 / 0.21
Jared Goff DETpassing yards250+YES0.5862%4%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.57 / 0.58
Khalil Shakir BUFreceptions4+NO0.4246%4%4.5 (46% over)2.954.050.58 / 0.66
Dawson Knox BUFreceiving yards25+YES0.2629%4%12.5 (50% over)21.1320.060.21 / 0.26
Khalil Shakir BUFreceptions5+NO0.5862%4%4.5 (46% over)2.954.050.42 / 0.43
Isaac TeSlaa DETreceiving yards15+NO0.4953%4%15.5 (52% over)12.5720.50.51 / 0.53
Josh Allen BUFrushing yards40+YES0.3437%4%30.5 (50% over)36.3137.570.31 / 0.34
Isaac TeSlaa DETreceiving yards40+NO0.8085%4%15.5 (52% over)12.5720.50.2 / 0.21
Keon Coleman BUFreceptions2+YES0.3841%3%1.5 (36% over)1.881.490.37 / 0.38
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards60+NO0.6367%3%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.37 / 0.4
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceptions7+NO0.4447%3%7.5 (49% over)5.327.010.56 / 0.6
DJ Moore BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.6670%3%0.5 (33% over)0.250.360.34 / 0.35
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards80+NO0.7074%3%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.3 / 0.33
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceptions5+NO0.6569%3%3.5 (58% over)2.33.660.35 / 0.37
DJ Moore BUFreceiving yards40+NO0.3235%2%62.5 (50% over)35.0859.750.68 / 0.74
Jared Goff DETpassing yards225+YES0.7175%2%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.7 / 0.71
Josh Allen BUFrushing yards30+NO0.4649%2%30.5 (50% over)36.3137.570.54 / 0.55
Josh Allen BUFinterceptions1+YES0.4144%2%0.5 (42% over)0.620.570.4 / 0.41
Keon Coleman BUFtouchdowns1+YES0.1617%2%0.5 (17% over)0.20.190.15 / 0.16
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards50+YES0.8486%2%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.82 / 0.84
DJ Moore BUFreceptions6+NO0.7477%1%4.5 (49% over)2.133.950.26 / 0.32
Sam LaPorta DETreceptions5+NO0.5760%1%4.5 (46% over)3.374.210.43 / 0.44
James Cook III BUFrushing yards70+YES0.5962%1%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.58 / 0.59
Keon Coleman BUFreceiving yards25+YES0.3234%1%13.5 (50% over)28.27230.29 / 0.32
James Cook III BUFrushing yards60+YES0.6972%1%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.67 / 0.69
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceptions6+NO0.3234%1%7.5 (49% over)5.327.010.68 / 0.74
Josh Allen BUFtouchdowns2+NO0.8586%1%0.5 (51% over)0.480.640.15 / 0.16
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards25+YES0.8485%0%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.79 / 0.84
Jared Goff DETpassing yards200+YES0.8284%0%270.5 (50% over)279.42272.640.79 / 0.82
Sam LaPorta DETreceiving yards40+NO0.4547%0%46.5 (50% over)38.4349.510.55 / 0.6
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceiving yards80+NO0.5355%0%79.5 (50% over)69.3881.960.47 / 0.48
Dawson Knox BUFreceptions3+YES0.2022%0%1.5 (42% over)1.641.560.08 / 0.2
Dalton Kincaid BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.6971%-0%0.5 (33% over)0.220.340.31 / 0.32
Jameson Williams DETreceptions5+NO0.6163%-0%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.39 / 0.4
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards275+YES0.3537%-0%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.34 / 0.35
Khalil Shakir BUFreceptions6+NO0.7476%-1%4.5 (46% over)2.954.050.26 / 0.3
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards25+NO0.4143%-1%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.59 / 0.62
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceptions4+NO0.4042%-1%4.5 (42% over)4.314.290.6 / 0.62
DJ Moore BUFreceptions7+NO0.8686%-1%4.5 (49% over)2.133.950.14 / 0.21
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards40+YES0.3436%-1%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.29 / 0.34
Jahmyr Gibbs DETtouchdowns2+NO0.6869%-1%0.5 (69% over)0.971.120.32 / 0.33
Jared Goff DETinterceptions1+YES0.4951%-1%0.5 (51% over)0.690.70.48 / 0.49
Sam LaPorta DETreceiving yards45+NO0.5253%-1%46.5 (50% over)38.4349.510.48 / 0.53
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceptions6+NO0.7172%-1%4.5 (42% over)4.314.290.29 / 0.3
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards70+YES0.6869%-1%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.64 / 0.68
Dawson Knox BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.8787%-1%0.5 (13% over)0.140.140.13 / 0.14
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards70+NO0.6566%-2%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.35 / 0.4
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceptions9+NO0.7071%-2%7.5 (49% over)5.327.010.3 / 0.34
Sam LaPorta DETtouchdowns1+NO0.7273%-2%0.5 (30% over)0.220.320.28 / 0.29
Dawson Knox BUFreceiving yards15+YES0.4546%-2%12.5 (50% over)21.1320.060.43 / 0.45
Josh Allen BUFrushing yards50+YES0.2527%-2%30.5 (50% over)36.3137.570.21 / 0.25
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards100+YES0.4142%-2%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.39 / 0.41
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards100+NO0.8685%-2%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.14 / 0.19
James Cook III BUFrushing yards80+YES0.5152%-2%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.5 / 0.51
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards300+YES0.2325%-2%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.22 / 0.23
Khalil Shakir BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.7373%-2%0.5 (30% over)0.210.310.27 / 0.28
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards30+NO0.5051%-2%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.5 / 0.51
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceptions2+NO0.1617%-2%3.5 (58% over)2.33.660.84 / 0.9
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards70+NO0.7575%-2%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.25 / 0.31
James Cook III BUFrushing yards50+YES0.8181%-3%78.5 (50% over)94.89890.77 / 0.81
Josh Allen BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.5253%-3%0.5 (51% over)0.480.640.48 / 0.49
Isaac TeSlaa DETtouchdowns1+NO0.8685%-3%0.5 (15% over)0.180.170.14 / 0.15
James Cook III BUFtouchdowns2+NO0.8282%-3%0.5 (57% over)0.630.770.18 / 0.22
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETtouchdowns1+NO0.5858%-3%0.5 (45% over)0.410.540.42 / 0.43
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceptions11+NO0.8887%-3%7.5 (49% over)5.327.010.12 / 0.16
Ray Davis BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.8786%-3%0.5 (15% over)0.130.160.13 / 0.14
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards200+YES0.7777%-3%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.75 / 0.77
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceptions6+NO0.8181%-3%3.5 (58% over)2.33.660.19 / 0.25
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards90+NO0.8887%-3%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.12 / 0.17
Dalton Kincaid BUFreceiving yards80+NO0.8282%-3%49.5 (53% over)33.2751.710.18 / 0.22
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards40+NO0.3233%-3%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.68 / 0.7
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceiving yards40+YES0.8684%-3%79.5 (50% over)69.3881.960.78 / 0.86
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards325+NO0.8785%-3%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.13 / 0.16
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards175+YES0.8886%-3%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.83 / 0.88
Khalil Shakir BUFreceiving yards80+YES0.1617%-3%44.5 (50% over)42.2249.120.11 / 0.16
Khalil Shakir BUFreceptions3+NO0.2728%-3%4.5 (46% over)2.954.050.73 / 0.78
Josh Allen BUFrushing yards25+NO0.4041%-4%30.5 (50% over)36.3137.570.6 / 0.61
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards250+NO0.4949%-4%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.51 / 0.52
Jahmyr Gibbs DETtouchdowns1+NO0.3233%-4%0.5 (69% over)0.971.120.68 / 0.69
Keon Coleman BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.8583%-4%0.5 (17% over)0.20.190.15 / 0.16
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceiving yards110+NO0.7877%-4%79.5 (50% over)69.3881.960.22 / 0.26
Jameson Williams DETtouchdowns1+NO0.7271%-4%0.5 (32% over)0.250.340.28 / 0.29
James Cook III BUFtouchdowns1+NO0.4646%-4%0.5 (57% over)0.630.770.54 / 0.55
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceiving yards15+YES0.7776%-4%29.5 (50% over)35.6536.580.75 / 0.77
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards150+NO0.8986%-4%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.11 / 0.12
Ray Davis BUFtouchdowns1+YES0.1414%-4%0.5 (15% over)0.130.160.13 / 0.14
Khalil Shakir BUFreceiving yards50+YES0.4040%-4%44.5 (50% over)42.2249.120.37 / 0.4
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards110+YES0.3435%-4%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.32 / 0.34
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceiving yards100+NO0.7271%-4%79.5 (50% over)69.3881.960.28 / 0.31
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards80+NO0.4040%-5%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.6 / 0.62
Jahmyr Gibbs DETrushing yards90+YES0.5151%-5%90.5 (50% over)98.3497.80.49 / 0.51
Sam LaPorta DETreceiving yards50+NO0.6059%-5%46.5 (50% over)38.4349.510.4 / 0.46
Jameson Williams DETreceiving yards90+NO0.8280%-5%59.5 (50% over)47.3561.320.18 / 0.26
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceptions5+NO0.5958%-5%4.5 (42% over)4.314.290.41 / 0.42
Isaac TeSlaa DETtouchdowns1+YES0.1515%-5%0.5 (15% over)0.180.170.14 / 0.15
Josh Allen BUFpassing yards225+YES0.6665%-5%250.5 (50% over)252.19251.010.64 / 0.66
Jameson Williams DETreceptions7+NO0.8986%-5%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.11 / 0.12
Jameson Williams DETreceptions6+NO0.7876%-5%3.5 (60% over)3.084.010.22 / 0.28
Jahmyr Gibbs DETreceptions5+YES0.4242%-5%4.5 (42% over)4.314.290.41 / 0.42
Amon-Ra St. Brown DETreceiving yards130+NO0.9086%-5%79.5 (50% over)69.3881.960.1 / 0.16
Tetairoa McMillan CARreceiving yards50+NO0.4074%80%none yet37.1837.180.6 / 0.62
Derrick Henry BALrushing yards140+YES0.1527%76%none yet114.65114.650.02 / 0.15
Jalen Hurts PHIrushing yards15+NO0.3258%75%none yet18.0518.050.68 / 0.83
DeVonta Smith PHIreceiving yards60+NO0.4679%68%none yet39.7439.740.54 / 0.55
Ashton Jeanty LVArushing yards40+NO0.3356%64%none yet42.4342.430.67 / 0.82
Terry McLaurin WASreceiving yards50+NO0.4980%60%none yet31.1831.180.51 / 0.55
Tony Pollard TENrushing yards25+NO0.3355%60%none yet28.9928.990.67 / 0.82
Kenneth Walker KCKtouchdowns1+NO0.3964%60%none yet0.440.440.61 / 0.64
Tetairoa McMillan CARreceiving yards60+NO0.5082%59%none yet37.1837.180.5 / 0.51
David Montgomery HOUtouchdowns1+NO0.4674%57%none yet0.30.30.54 / 0.55
Devaughn Vele NODreceiving yards25+NO0.4064%56%none yet23.8523.850.6 / 0.74
Saquon Barkley PHIrushing yards80+NO0.5384%55%none yet48.8148.810.47 / 0.51

Report card

First graded week lands after the first full week of published packs.

How

Stat lines come from the same engine as the DFS projections. Spread of outcomes is calibrated on 2025 residuals: yards follow a Gamma with variance ≈ 24 × mean; receptions a negative binomial; touchdowns and interceptions Poisson. Every input is open data — Kalshi's documented public API, Pinnacle's guest API, ESPN's scoreboard, nflverse — see the data policy.